Akola Riots Case: Police Must Stay Unbiased, Says Supreme Court

Fast Summary

• Supreme Court Judgment: On September 11, 2025, teh Supreme Court warned against communal bias in police conduct and ordered the formation of a Special Examination Team (SIT) by the Maharashtra goverment. The SIT must include equal portrayal from Hindu and Muslim officers.
• Incident Overview: A 17-year-old Muslim boy, Mohammad afzal Mohammad Sharif, alleged witnessing the murder of Vilas Mahadevrao Gaikwad during Akola riots in May 2023. He was assaulted by suspected assailants and faced police apathy when attempting to file complaints.
• Key details:

– Gaikwad was reportedly killed due to mistaken identity as a Muslim.
– Afzal’s appeals to both local police and Akola’s Superintendent of Police were ignored.- Justice Sanjay Kumar criticized negligence by law enforcement, stressing unbiased duty execution.

• Court Instructions:

– SIT should investigate allegations thoroughly with a report due in three months.
– Maharashtra Home Secretary must take disciplinary action against negligent officials.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The Supreme Court’s directive underscores concerns about communal bias within law enforcement agencies-a critical issue for India’s democratic fabric. Ensuring neutrality among institutional frameworks is vital not only for upholding justice but also for fostering social harmony amidst deeply polarized environments like communal riots. The unprecedented move to mandate religiously diverse composition within an investigative team aims to establish trustworthiness while probing sensitive matters.

Moreover, the court’s emphasis on accountability through disciplinary actions against negligent officers advocates stronger standards of governance-a necessity if faith in state institutions is to be preserved.This judgment could potentially set legal benchmarks on handling communal tensions equitably at both regional and national levels.

Read more