Uncovering the Dark Truths of Lobotomy’s History

Speedy Summary

• The lobotomy was developed as a radical treatment for mental illness in the early 20th century amidst overcrowded and underfunded psychiatric institutions.
• António Egas Moniz, a Portuguese neurologist, refined earlier failed procedures to create the “leucotomy” in 1935 and controversially won the Nobel Prize for physiology or Medicine in 1949.
• American physician Walter Freeman popularized a crude version called “transorbital lobotomy,” performed with an ice pick-like tool driven through the eye socket-a quicker method that required less sterilization or anesthesia.
• By the late 1940s, over 40,000 lobotomies were conducted in the U.S., even on children as young as twelve, often used to pacify non-compliant individuals rather than treat severe psychoses.
• One famous case involved Rosemary Kennedy, whose botched lobotomy left her severely impaired; her tragedy later propelled social initiatives like Special Olympics advocacy led by her sister Eunice Kennedy Shriver.
• Mortality rates exceeded 5%, alongside widespread side effects like apathy, cognitive decline, seizures, loss of personality traits-even death during procedures due to reckless surgeries like Freeman’s infamous demonstrations.
• The practice largely ended by the late 1960s due to rising ethical concerns and advancements such as antipsychotic medications.

Read More

Indian Opinion Analysis

The history of lobotomies offers sobering lessons on medical ethics and patient welfare not just globally but also within India’s evolving healthcare system. With increasing reliance on solutions for mental health challenges today-from invasive treatments to psychosocial interventions-this dark chapter underscores why scientific rigor must precede therapeutic adoption everywhere.

for a country navigating both traditional practices and modern psychiatry amid stigma surrounding mental illness management systems growing rapidly-India might view this grim precedent critically regarding informed consent principles that align with progressive care models globally safeguarding against misuse potentially paralleling Lobotomy-era misapplications themselves